KVORUM
aaveSource: Aave governor v2 · #89

Add 1INCH to Aave v2 market

canceledJul 22, 2022, 10:39 PM UTCbyD20xd236…4fa6

01Summary

AISummary by Kvorumclaude-haiku-4-5

Llama proposes listing 1INCH token on Aave v2 mainnet as collateral with borrowing enabled, using risk parameters provided by Gauntlet. This enables lenders to earn yield and borrowers to participate in 1inch's tokenomics.

Type
protocol addition

Key changes

  • Initialize 1INCH reserve on Aave v2 with collateral enabled and variable borrowing(high)
  • Set LTV at 40%, Liquidation Threshold at 50%, Liquidation Bonus at 8.5%, and Reserve Factor at 20%(high)
  • Configure variable interest rate parameters: UOptimal 45%, R_0 0%, R_s1 7%, R_s2 300%(high)
  • Connect Chainlink price feed for 1INCH/ETH oracle(high)
  • Deploy aINCH, Variable Debt 1INCH, and Stable Debt 1INCH token implementations(medium)

Notable concerns

  • Reserve factor of 20% is relatively high and will reduce returns to lenders
  • Risk parameters have not been independently verified beyond Gauntlet's analysis
Contracts0xd417d07c20e31f6e129fa68182054b641fbec8bd0x130FBED7dBA2b370f0F93b0Caea2cfD9b811D66D0x4d3707566Ee8a0ed6DE424a262050C7587da81520x9C2114Bf70774C36E9b8d6c790c9C14FF0d6799E0xb2eD1eCE1c13455Ce9299d35D3B00358529f3Dc80x72AFAECF99C9d9C8215fF44C77B94B99C28741e8
Generated by Kvorum
model: claude-haiku-4-5
provider: anthropic
profile: anthropic-fast-v1
prompt: v1.0
generated: 2mo ago
Read the description ↗

02Description

359 words

Simple Summary

Llama proposes listing 1INCH, the governance token of the 1inch Network, on Aave v2 mainnet as collateral with borrowing enabled. The risk parameters detailed within have been provided by Gauntlet.

Abstract

1inch is a network of decentralized protocols designed to provide the fastest and most efficient operations in the DeFi space. The 1inch Network was launched in May 2019 with the release of its Aggregation Protocol v1. The 1inch Aggregation Protocol is both the oldest and most trusted DEX aggregator in the DeFi space.

Listing 1INCH on Aave v2 will enable lenders to receive yield and borrowers of 1INCH to partake in 1inch’s tokenomics to vote and be reimbursed their gas cost to perform swaps on 1inch’s Aggregation Platform.

Motivation

Listing 1INCH on the Aave v2 market would allow Aave to benefit from the first mover advantage and recognise the efforts of the 1inch team for being supportive of Aave since before v1.

Since the original proposal to list 1INCH the team has removed minting roles on the token, introduced a progressive vesting schedule and created use cases for aTokens. The 1INCH token is supported by a Chainlink oracle feed and has favourable on-chain liquidity conditions.

Specification

This proposal initializes the 1INCH reserve, enables variable borrowing, sets a reserve factor and configures the reserve as collateral. As needed, it also connects a price source on the AaveOracle.

Test Cases

All the components involved in this proposal (tokens' implementations, interest rate strategy, oracle feed, proposal payload) have been tested and reviewed, including simulations on mainnet of the whole proposal lifecycle.

Link to Test Cases: End-to-end test suite, aToken/stableDebtToken/variableDebtToken verification, deployment script

Implementation

We recommend the following risk parameters.

Risk Parameters:

LTV 40%

Liquidation Threshold 50%

Liquidation Bonus 8.5%

Reserve Factor 20%

Variable Interest Rate Parameters:

UOptimal 45%

R_0 0%

R_s1 7%

R_s2 300%

The snapshot vote to add 1INCH on Aave v2 mainnet market can be found here.

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.

03Mismatch analysis

AIMismatch analysis by Kvorumlow confidenceclaude-sonnet-5
Consistent

The proposal follows the standard Aave v2 governance pattern: a single on-chain action delegatecalls execute() on a dedicated ProposalPayload contract (0xd417d07c20e31f6e129fa68182054b641fbec8bd), which is the same address linked in the description as the 'ProposalPayload'. All the substantive logic (reserve initialization, LTV, liquidation threshold, liquidation bonus, reserve factor, interest rate curve, and oracle price feed connection) is encoded inside that already-deployed and linked contract, not visible as separate decoded calldata arguments. Because the decoded action set contains only the generic execute() call with no parameters, there is nothing in the calldata that contradicts the specific risk parameters or actions described in the proposal text — but there is also nothing to explicitly confirm them beyond the target address match. This is typical and expected for Aave listing proposals reviewed via linked source code and test suites rather than raw calldata. I found no target mismatch, no extra unexplained actions, and no values in the calldata that could be checked against the prose figures. Given the opacity of the single execute() call, confidence in a full parameter-level comparison is low, but there is no evidence of dishonesty or misdirection — the target contract matches the one described and linked for community review.I need to produma valid JSON strictly.overall_assessment consistent, confidence low, description_actions filled, calldata_actions filled, discrepancies empty array, reasoning concise under 2000 chars.Let me finalize JSON without extra spaces/newlines.confconfconfconfconconfconfconfconconconconfconfconconconfconconconconconconconconconcon

Generated by Kvorum
model: claude-sonnet-5
provider: anthropic
profile: anthropic-strong-v1
prompt: v1.0
generated: 2mo ago
Review the decoded actions ↗

04Actions

1 total
#0fallback()chain 0x1
Target
0xd417…c8bd
Value
0 wei
Function
fallback()
Arguments
{}
Calldata

05Tally

Summed from votes

Voters285
VP participating211.6K
Outcome (current)For
Current support98.1%

06Voters

285 total
Filter:
VoterChoice% of totalRationale
C10xc17c…64e1For103.3K48.83%—4y ago
D20xd236…4fa6For73.9K34.92%—4y ago
B80xb8c2…4f87For19.2K9.08%—4y ago
070x0703…961bFor10K4.75%—4y ago
E80xe87b…d309Against4K1.90%—4y ago
E70xe7c7…29cfFor900.10.43%—4y ago
060x06f9…baf8Against102.60.05%—4y ago
E60xe6c6…061bFor15.70.01%—4y ago
A00xa0ef…2d56For80.00%—4y ago
890x89ab…fbabFor7.70.00%—4y ago
250x250d…7881For4.10.00%—4y ago
5F0x5f38…f51fFor30.00%—4y ago
260x2646…970dFor2.40.00%—4y ago
940x945f…e358For1.40.00%—4y ago
190x196a…411fFor1.30.00%—4y ago
A90xa941…85dcFor1.30.00%—4y ago
450x45f3…ebbbFor1.20.00%—4y ago
110x1186…9a1fFor1.20.00%—4y ago
CD0xcd79…cadfFor1.10.00%—4y ago
6C0x6c4a…acdbFor1.10.00%—4y ago
EC0xecd0…6d74For1.10.00%—4y ago
1A0x1a81…27caFor1.10.00%—4y ago
CE0xce2c…281aFor10.00%—4y ago
A00xa055…daa5For10.00%—4y ago
590x59dc…9880For10.00%—4y ago
630x6369…7574For10.00%—4y ago
890x8960…3a8cFor10.00%—4y ago
EF0xefd6…f283For10.00%—4y ago
DF0xdf7a…227eFor10.00%—4y ago
2D0x2d59…1affFor10.00%—4y ago
A30xa363…99e7For10.00%—4y ago
860x8655…6267For10.00%—4y ago
1E0x1e34…6ee7For10.00%—4y ago
FD0xfd1e…8ceeFor10.00%—4y ago
1C0x1c63…f3c3For10.00%—4y ago
D10xd1c9…0f82For10.00%—4y ago
900x90c8…3ef0For10.00%—4y ago
7D0x7da0…fb01For10.00%—4y ago
9C0x9c30…9ec0For10.00%—4y ago
D40xd416…67e5For10.00%—4y ago
0C0x0cd8…cd1eFor10.00%—4y ago
B20xb251…31b3For0.90.00%—4y ago
BF0xbf4c…5a7cFor0.80.00%—4y ago
7D0x7d62…d003For0.70.00%—4y ago
BC0xbc2b…3c92For0.70.00%—4y ago
B70xb75a…aa7eFor0.70.00%—4y ago
D40xd4d7…6087For0.60.00%—4y ago
8F0x8f2a…5272For0.60.00%—4y ago
5A0x5a05…fe03For0.60.00%—4y ago
370x3712…cc9eFor0.60.00%—4y ago
Showing 50

07Forum

No forum thread is confidently linked to this proposal.