KVORUM
aaveSource: Aave governor v2 · #41

Institute a Voting Delay Period

defeatedOct 25, 2021, 02:40 AM UTCby680x683a…6c02

01Summary

AISummary by Kvorumclaude-haiku-4-5

Proposal to increase the voting delay period for Aave governance proposals from 0 to 2 days (172,800 seconds) to allow more time for analysis and review before voting begins on complex proposals.

Type
governance change

Key changes

  • Set votingDelay parameter to 172,800 seconds (2 days) on core governance contract, creating a formal analysis period before voting can begin on proposals(high)
  • Voting will no longer begin immediately upon proposal submission; there will now be a 2-day review window for pre-vote analysis(high)

Notable concerns

  • Guardian intervention may be marginally more likely if time-sensitive issues arise during the 2-day delay period
  • Risk parameterization changes identified by Gauntlet will experience additional delay until a riskAdmin role is implemented
Contracts0xec568fffba86c094cf06b22134b23074dfe2252c
Generated by Kvorum
model: claude-haiku-4-5
provider: anthropic
profile: anthropic-fast-v1
prompt: v1.0
generated: 2mo ago
Read the description ↗

02Description

276 words

Simple Summary

A proposal to increase the voting delay period for all on-chain governance proposals (AIPs).

Background

Aave governance proposals (AIPs) vary in complexity, scope, and impact. As Aave continues to make progress on its growth trajectory, it is becoming obvious that certain proposals need to allow more time for pre-vote analysis. For instance, AIP-33: Add FEI to Aave V2 was, fortunately, able to be canceled, via delegation removal, rather than needing to use the Aave Guardian.

This month has seen the most governance proposals (9) of any month since Aave V2 has launched with no sign of slowing given the variety of authors and proposal type.

Proposal

A formal analysis period is defined as a non-voting period where a proposal is active (e.g. submitted on-chain). Currently, the votingDelay configured on Aave governance is set to 0 - voting begins immediately when proposals are created.

We propose to set this voting delay to 2 days, in seconds, using the setVotingDelay method on the core governance contract. Setting the votingDelay will cause there to be a new review period between the proposal submission and when voting for that proposal begins.

Potential Side Effects

  • The Guardian is marginally more likely to be needed should time sensitive issues arise.
  • Gauntlet’s risk parameterization will see a delay from time to identifying a suboptimal risk parameter to executing a change. At least until a riskAdmin role is implemented.

Implementation

We set the voting delay using setVotingDelay on the core governance contract located at 0xEC568fffba86c094cf06b22134B23074DFE2252c, with a delay of 172800 seconds, or 2 days.

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.

03Mismatch analysis

AIMismatch analysis by Kvorumclaude-sonnet-5
Consistent

The proposal describes a single action: calling setVotingDelay with a value of 172800 seconds (2 days) on the Aave governance contract at 0xEC568fffba86c094cf06b22134B23074DFE2252c. The decoded calldata shows exactly one action, calling setVotingDelay(172800) on 0xec568fffba86c094cf06b22134b23074dfe2252c. The function name, argument value, and target address all match (case-insensitive Ethereum addresses are equivalent). There is a minor typographical discrepancy in the description's address string, which appears to contain one extra character compared to a standard 40-hex-character address, but this is clearly a copy-paste/typo issue rather than a substantive redirection, since the calldata's actual target matches the well-known Aave governance contract address referenced elsewhere in the proposal (including the Etherscan link). No other actions, transfers, role grants, or parameter changes are present in the calldata beyond what is described. Given the single, clearly matching action with no hidden side effects, funds movement, or scope changes, this proposal is consistent with its description.

Generated by Kvorum
model: claude-sonnet-5
provider: anthropic
profile: anthropic-strong-v1
prompt: v1.0
generated: 2mo ago
Review the decoded actions ↗

04Actions

1 total
#0setVotingDelay(uint256)chain 0x1
Target
0xec56…252c
Value
0 wei
Function
setVotingDelay(uint256)
Arguments
{
  "votingDelay": "172800"
}
Calldata

05Tally

Summed from votes

Voters27
VP participating1M
Outcome (current)For
Current support100%

06Voters

27 total
Filter:
VoterChoice% of totalRationale
DD0xdd70…8202For224.3K21.71%—5y ago
F60xf63e…78c8For125.9K12.18%—5y ago
9B0x9b5e…0499For110.2K10.66%—5y ago
C10xc17c…64e1For103.3K10.00%—5y ago
990x990d…f1c2For100K9.67%—5y ago
C40xc4a9…2935For92.5K8.95%—5y ago
5B0x5bc9…d76cFor84.9K8.21%—5y ago
0C0x0c94…297bFor83.7K8.10%—5y ago
FC0xfc56…5e0cFor65.2K6.31%—5y ago
CF0xcfec…28e8For21K2.03%—5y ago
450x458c…730eFor10K0.97%—5y ago
800x80dc…c146For3.7K0.36%—5y ago
700x704d…a0dfFor3.5K0.33%—5y ago
680x683a…6c02For3.1K0.30%—5y ago
F50xf569…271bFor1.1K0.11%—5y ago
3A0x3a25…e9d2For5900.06%—5y ago
6C0x6cd7…9248For156.30.02%—5y ago
8D0x8d07…a265For500.00%—5y ago
AD0xad54…99d1For42.60.00%—5y ago
BC0xbca7…e0d5For20.60.00%—5y ago
270x2713…d6e5For15.30.00%—5y ago
A00xa0ef…2d56For80.00%—5y ago
780x78b3…447bFor6.60.00%—5y ago
B60xb6e8…9fcdFor1.90.00%—5y ago
780x78ab…d032For0.90.00%—5y ago
100x102e…67b5For0.50.00%—5y ago
DC0xdc7b…c0caFor00.00%—5y ago
Showing 27

07Forum

No forum thread is confidently linked to this proposal.