KVORUM
aaveSource: Aave governor v2 · #22

Add BarnBridge (BOND) to Aave

defeatedAug 5, 2021, 03:51 PM UTCby370x378a…2302

01Summary

AISummary by Kvorumclaude-haiku-4-5

Proposal to add BarnBridge's BOND token as collateral to Aave v2 with conservative parameters (25% LTV, 35% liquidation threshold). BOND is a governance token for the BarnBridge risk tokenization protocol. BarnBridge currently provides ~$180M in stablecoin liquidity to Aave v2. This addition would enable the BarnBridge DAO and BOND holders to borrow against their positions and provide lending yield opportunities on Aave.

Type
protocol addition

Key changes

  • Add BOND token as collateral asset to Aave v2 with LTV of 25%, liquidation threshold of 35%, and liquidation bonus of 15%(high)
  • Enable BOND holders to borrow stablecoins against their positions and earn lending yield(medium)
  • Configure price oracle via Chainlink BOND/ETH feed for BOND pricing(medium)
  • Set reserve factor at 35% with variable rate model (R_0: 0%, R_s1: 7%, R_s2: 300%) and stable rate model (R_s1: 10%, R_s2: 300%)(medium)

Notable concerns

  • BOND token exhibits high volatility
  • Conservative collateral parameters (25% LTV) suggest risk assessment by proposer
  • BOND has relatively small holder base (6.3k) and moderate social media presence
  • Proposer disclosed as seed investor in BarnBridge, presenting potential conflict of interest
Contracts0x0391D2021f89DC339F60Fff84546EA23E337750f0x170375B4aD477133a36B4961D9bcA6D5BF9C83890xb98EF546D1057f9750511FE16cBCC7Eb0FB6451F0x21D0366D1D678fCf276954b7D651B9dfeE104D820x273358d06Ca3862bf3C0691d1C8B4B4d3E9064580xe775a3a0a1cdc50bd48d5f47c442a0a4f5f244730xa50ba011c48153de246e5192c8f9258a2ba79ca9
Generated by Kvorum
model: claude-haiku-4-5
provider: anthropic
profile: anthropic-fast-v1
prompt: v1.0
generated: 2mo ago
Read the description ↗

02Description

1,058 words

Simple Summary

We are proposing to add BarnBridge (BOND) to Aave as collateral.

Abstract

BarnBridge is building a suite of applications that allows users to mitigate risk across various use cases throughout DeFi. These applications rely on differentiated user profiles, referred to as tranches, in order to create markets for risks such as interest rate fluctuations and asset price volatility. Currently, SMART Yield on Ethereum mainnet has some $290M in TVL, while SMART Exposure and SMART Alpha are slated for Q3 of 2021. The BOND token is used to govern the BarnBridge DAO and allocate protocol resources.

Motivation

BarnBridge is one of a handful of DAOs noted for its sizable allocation of its own native asset (see: open-orgs.info). It currently holds over 30% of the total BOND supply.

Adding BOND to Aave would provide a mechanism through which the DAO could finance growth, decreasing the need for excessive token distributions. Example use cases include: funding projects building on top of BarnBridge applications, paying salaries to key protocol participants, and hosting bug bounties that earn yield until paid out.

BarnBridge earns fee revenues from both deposits of underlying assets and redemptions of derivative assets. By adding BOND as collateral, the DAO and individual BOND holders can borrow against their position, increasing stablecoin demand and utilization on Aave v2. Additionally, BOND holders can lend out their position for a yield on Aave v2. Given BarnBridge’s direct role as an Aave liquidity provider, the addition of BOND to Aave v2 creates more synergies between Aave and BOND holders.

To start, it may make sense for BOND to have a conservative LTV and liquidation threshold which can be fine tuned further down the line.

Specification

  1. What is the link between the author of the AIP and the Asset?
  • Seed investor in BarnBridge
  1. Provide a brief high-level overview of the project and the token
  • BarnBridge is a risk tokenizing protocol. It aims to reduce the risks associated with DeFi, such as inflation risk, market price risk, and cash-flow volatility risk. By letting users select a risk profile, BarnBridge can redistribute risk via tokenized, liquid tranches. BarnBridge does this with its SMART Yield, SMART Exposure, and SMART Alpha products, all of which address a specific DeFi risk category.

  • BOND token is a governance token that powers the BarnBridge DAO protocol. BOND is an ERC-20 token. Token holders have the ability to govern the network by staking their holdings in return for the right to participate in on-chain voting and make decisions on the protocol development.

  • BOND total supply: 10,000,000 (minting function is disabled).

  • Token contract address: 0x0391D2021f89DC339F60Fff84546EA23E337750f

  1. Explain positioning of token in the Aave ecosystem. Why would it be a good borrow or collateral asset?
  • By adding BOND as collateral, the DAO and individual BOND holders can borrow against their position, increasing stablecoin demand and utilization on Aave v2. Additionally, BOND holders can lend out their position for a yield on Aave v2. Given BarnBridge’s direct role as an Aave liquidity provider, the addition of BOND to Aave v2 creates more synergies between Aave and BOND holders. BarnBridge currently provides ~$180M in liquidity to Aave v2 and will be launching a similar integration on Polygon in July.
  1. Provide a brief history of the project and the different components: DAO (is it live?), products (are the live?). How did it overcome some of the challenges it faced?
  • BarnBridge was founded in September 2020. Since that time, BarnBridge succeed in launching the BarnBridge DAO and delivering a SMART Yield product which currently holds $280M+ in TVL with $178M providing to Aave. With the upcoming SMART Yield and SMART Exposure launch on Polygon, followed by the product we call SMART Secret and SMART Alpha (later) BarnBridge will be a full-established protocol with plenty of products and potentially with 1B+ in TVL after all our products launch.
  1. How is the asset currently used?
  • BOND token is currently used for:

    • Staking in BarnBridge DAO to get exposure to voting rights in the DAO.
    • Liquidity providing on Uniswap, Sushiswap, and Bancor.
    • Lending on Cream finance.
  1. Emission schedule

BarnBridge BOND emission schedule

  1. Token & protocol permissions and upgradeability
  • Protocol is upgraded by the BarnBridge DAO. We used the Diamond Standard on a couple parts of the protocol so we could do seamless upgrades. A users token "power" determines their vote weight and control they have in the DAO.
  1. Market data (Market Cap, 24h Volume, Volatility, Exchanges, Maturity)
  • Market cap: $96M
  • 24h Volume: $5.7M
  • Volatility: high
  • Exchanges: Coinbase, Uniswap, Bancor, Gemini
  1. Social channels data (Size of communities, activity on Github)
  • Twitter: 19.4K
  • Discord: 6.2K
  • Medium: 4.1K
  1. Contracts date of deployments, number of transactions, number of holders for tokens
  • Transactions: 116K
  • Token holders: 6.3k

Rationale

BarnBridge will continue to grow as a distributor of Aave v2 stablecoin markets as its SMART Yield integration gains further traction. There are currently ~$180M worth of stablecoins deposited into Aave v2 through SMART Yield. This liquidity is provided without any expectation of being used, meaning BarnBridge is a pure liquidity provider for Aave. BarnBridge is also actively building an integration with Aave’s Polygon market. Future BarnBridge products, including SMART Alpha senior tranches for assets like wBTC and ETH, stand to provide Aave with relatively safer collateral given their ability to mitigate price drawdowns.

Test Cases

Test cases for an implementation are mandatory for AIPs but can be included with the implementation.

Implementation

Contracts

Price oracle

The BOND price oracle will be served via ChainLink, which includes the BOND/ETH feed, here.

Interest model

  • LTV 25%
  • Liquidation Threshold 35%
  • Liquidation Bonus 15%
  • Reserve Factor 35%

Interest Rate Model

  • UOptimal 45%

Variable:

  • R_0 0%
  • R_s1 7%
  • R_s2 300%

Stable:

  • R_s1 10%
  • R_s2 300%

BarnBridge BOND Aave interest rates

References

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.

03Mismatch analysis

AIMismatch analysis by Kvorum

A calldata-vs-description analysis is not generated yet. Review the decoded actions →

04Actions

2 total
#0execute(address,address,address,address,address,uint256,uint256,uint256,uint256,uint8,bool,bool,bool)chain 0x1
Target
0xe775…4473
Value
0 wei
Function
execute(address,address,address,address,address,uint256,uint256,uint256,uint256,uint8,bool,bool,bool)
Arguments
{
  "0": "0x0391D2021f89DC339F60Fff84546EA23E337750f",
  "1": "0x170375B4aD477133a36B4961D9bcA6D5BF9C8389",
  "2": "0xb98EF546D1057f9750511FE16cBCC7Eb0FB6451F",
  "3": "0x21D0366D1D678fCf276954b7D651B9dfeE104D82",
  "4": "0x273358d06Ca3862bf3C0691d1C8B4B4d3E906458",
  "5": "2500",
  "6": "3500",
  "7": "11500",
  "8": "3500",
  "9": "18",
  "10": true,
  "11": true,
  "12": true
}
Calldata
#1setAssetSources(address[],address[])chain 0x1
Target
0xa50b…9ca9
Value
0 wei
Function
setAssetSources(address[],address[])
Arguments
{
  "0": [
    "0x0391D2021f89DC339F60Fff84546EA23E337750f"
  ],
  "1": [
    "0xdd22A54e05410D8d1007c38b5c7A3eD74b855281"
  ]
}
Calldata

05Tally

Summed from votes

Voters71
VP participating965K
Outcome (current)Against
Current support36.6%

06Voters

71 total
Filter:
VoterChoice% of totalRationale
370x378a…2302For262.8K27.23%—5y ago
DD0xdd70…8202Against187.7K19.45%—5y ago
9B0x9b5e…0499Against109.6K11.36%—5y ago
100x10f8…1f92Against93.2K9.66%—5y ago
C40xc4a9…2935Against92.5K9.59%—5y ago
4B0x4bf0…40fcAgainst64.1K6.64%—5y ago
A30xa3f0…b233Against63.6K6.59%—5y ago
8D0x8db0…dbddFor33.8K3.50%—5y ago
3C0x3cb9…d491For21.9K2.27%—5y ago
450x458c…730eFor10K1.04%—5y ago
700x704d…a0dfFor5.2K0.54%—5y ago
5A0x5a27…1cddFor4.9K0.51%—5y ago
820x82a4…085aFor4.7K0.49%—5y ago
800x80dc…c146For2.9K0.30%—5y ago
510x510b…9938For1.6K0.16%—5y ago
F50xf569…271bFor1.1K0.12%—5y ago
5E0x5e75…d9b5For1K0.10%—5y ago
150x15a8…8738For898.70.09%—5y ago
CA0xca76…6f46Against5500.06%—5y ago
710x71f1…14b0For400.80.04%—5y ago
4A0x4ada…1c6bFor343.70.04%—5y ago
E40xe497…dd1aFor2500.03%—5y ago
2C0x2cbf…866dFor1740.02%—5y ago
CB0xcb2a…f2f4For173.70.02%—5y ago
2E0x2e72…1792For130.60.01%—5y ago
660x66b2…78deFor114.20.01%—5y ago
760x768c…8f1fFor110.50.01%—5y ago
B30xb311…bc93For107.60.01%—5y ago
100x10d6…7178For106.40.01%—5y ago
CF0xcfa6…e428For103.80.01%—5y ago
250x2502…1e2cFor103.80.01%—5y ago
E80xe888…66eeFor102.70.01%—5y ago
E90xe9b2…e786For100.10.01%—5y ago
800x80b3…6e1dFor97.30.01%—5y ago
7B0x7b23…dc6eAgainst960.01%—5y ago
000x00ce…12f9For86.10.01%—5y ago
7F0x7f18…caedFor75.10.01%—5y ago
810x81b1…d38dFor68.60.01%—5y ago
B20xb229…890bFor50.10.01%—5y ago
590x5993…b010For45.20.00%—5y ago
540x54e5…324aFor39.90.00%—5y ago
CA0xca54…73c6Against21.40.00%—5y ago
110x119a…853aFor17.70.00%—5y ago
860x86d0…3629For14.10.00%—5y ago
8A0x8aba…7940For11.70.00%—5y ago
8D0x8dc4…fa41For110.00%—5y ago
320x32cb…057fFor10.60.00%—5y ago
190x19b5…5188For10.30.00%—5y ago
070x07da…fcf1For8.90.00%—5y ago
A00xa0ef…2d56For80.00%—5y ago
Showing 50

07Forum

No forum thread is confidently linked to this proposal.