Aave Liquidity Commitee Funding
01Summary
Proposal to fund the Aave Liquidity Committee (ALC) with 500k GHO over 3 months to support GHO liquidity and DeFi integrations. Funds will be sourced by withdrawing 250k USDT and 250k USDC from the Aave V2 collector and swapping them for GHO.
- Type
- treasury allocation
- Funding
- $500000
Key changes
- Allocation of 500k GHO to Aave Liquidity Committee for 3-month liquidity and DeFi integration efforts(high)
- Withdrawal of 250k USDT and 250k USDC from Aave V2 collector for conversion to GHO(high)
- Budget allocation: 360k GHO for peg resilience and liquidity, 140k GHO for DeFi integrations(high)
- Continued support for concentrated liquidity positions on Maverick and Balancer E-CLP pools to improve GHO peg stability(medium)
Notable concerns
- Inherent uncertainty in future stablecoin rates and price volatility
- Success depends on continued Borrow Cap increases beyond current 35M bucket size
- External dependencies beyond ALC control for achieving performance targets
- Proposal excludes efforts to drive GHO liquidity beyond Ethereum
Generated by Kvorum
02Description
Summary
This publication proposes funding the Aave Liquidity Committee with 500k GHO to continue supporting GHO's liquidity and DeFi integrations over the next 3 months.
Motivation
Since its initial funding in October 2023, the Aave Liquidity Committee (previously GLC) has actively supported GHO liquidity across various DEXes by deploying and incentivising liquidity pools.
As a result of these efforts:
- Deeper on-chain liquidity
- Lower slippage, especially for GHO to USDC swaps
In combination with other efforts like stkGHO, ALC's initiatives have played a critical role in supporting GHO's peg recovery.
Throughout the period, the ALC leveraged on both Uniswap v3 and, more frequently, Maverick to tailor liquidity distribution at specific price ranges which helped absorb GHO downward market volatility. A list of active Boosted Positions can be found here.
While some pools are incentivised by voting with pre-existing DAO holdings (e.g. vlAURA), others like Maverick's concentrated liquidity Boosted Positions require additional expenses. It is worth noting, the Aave DAO is expected to benefit from the next airdrop by Maverick. We expect Maverick, and potentially Merkle on Uniswap v3, to remain key tools for supporting tailored liquidity shaping efforts in provided peg resilience.
Concentrated GHO liquidity was recently introduced in Balancer with the creation of several E-CLP pools. These pools are being jointly incentivised with use to the Aave DAO's vlAURA holding. When there is excess vlAURA votes, these votes have been delegated to Paladin in return for approximately 70% APR nominated in USDC.
The following charts depict some of the impact these efforts had on GHO's ecosystem, highlights:
- GHO/USDC Maverick pools captured most of the volume
- 0.2% bin width pool processed most of the volume during high volatility period
- 0.1% bin width pool is starting to replace the 0.2% bin width pool trading volume. This is due to incentive efforts shifting to Boosted Positions within the 0.1% bin width pool to create deeper liquidity and reducing price volatility
- GHO/USDC/USDT Balancer provides continuous yield source for LP
- Trading volumes and TVL on Balancer are expected to increase when the BPT is integrated by other protocols and leveraged farming is introduced
- Gyrsocope E-CLP pools on Balancer are starting to capture a larger share of the market volume in recent weeks
- As the peg improves, one pool will be retained and the dual token deposit requirement will help provide resilience for the peg
The next chapter for GHO focuses on the following key areas:
- 1.00:1.00 peg with USD
- Reducing price volatility
- Deeper liquidity to support DeFi integrations
- Grow non stable-coin-paired liquidity pools
- Targeted liquidity distributions to support Borrow Cap increases
These efforts will need to scale to match GHO's expected growth profile. The primary liquidity pools are to remain stable coins, and we expect to introduce other asset pairs in the future, as well as participation in the launch of various projects like Ethena and f(x) Protocol's launch.
Though there is inherent uncertainty in future stable coin rates, price volatility, and upcoming opportunities for new DeFi integrations, we believe a high-level budget will look like the following:
| Objective | Category | Budget |
|---|---|---|
| Liquidity | Peg Resilience | 360k GHO |
| DeFi Integrations | Create Utility | 140k GHO |
| Total | 500k GHO |
It is important to note that this estimation excludes efforts to drive GHO liquidity or integrations beyond Ethereum.
Performance Indicators
The below details some high level GHO metrics we propose tracking:
| Description | Optimal Value |
|---|---|
| TVL DEX Liquidity Pools | 50M |
| TVL in Utility Liquidity Pools | 15M excl. stkGHO |
| DEX Liquidity Composition | < 50% GHO (< 33% for 3pools) |
| Swap Price Impact $5M Swap | < 0.10% (GHO to USDC) |
| Annualised Peg Volatility | < 5.00% |
| Price level for > 90% time | $0.995 using Redstone Medium Price |
Please note, each of the above targets has external dependencies beyond the control of the ALC. The above table serves as a North Star for the ALC to strive towards over the next 3 months on the assumption the Borrow Cap is continually increased beyond the current 35M Bucket Size. Having measurable targets provides a clear direction and goal to achieve.
The stkGHO implementation, USDe integration and coordinated efforts to attract users to acquire GHO are all great examples of how growth initiatives drive GHO utility, adoption and have a positive impact the spot price.
Each of the above metrics, plus more, will be shown on the TokenLogic analytics dashboard.
Specification
Swap the following assets for GHO:
- Withdraw 250k Aave V2 USDT from the collector
- Withdraw 250k Aave V2 USDC from the collector
- Swap 250k USDT withdrawn above for GHO
- Swap 250k USDC withdrawn above for GHO
Create an allowance of 500k GHO to ALC SAFE.
ALC SAFE: 0x205e795336610f5131Be52F09218AF19f0f3eC60
References
- Implementation: AaveV3Ethereum
- Tests: AaveV3Ethereum
- Snapshot
- Discussion
Disclosure
TokenLogic and karpatkey receive no payment for this proposal. TokenLogic and karpatkey are both delegates within the Aave community.
Copyright
Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.
03Mismatch analysis
The proposal follows the standard Aave governance execution pattern: the on-chain calldata is a single call to execute() on a payload/executor contract, with no further decoding of the internal logic (withdrawals, swaps, GHO allowance to the ALC Safe) that the description claims will happen. Because the decoded action set only shows the outer execute() call and not the internal operations coded inside the payload contract (per the linked Solidity source), there is no way to directly verify, from the calldata alone, that the withdraw/swap/allowance amounts and recipient match the prose. Nothing in the available decoded data contradicts the description, but the lack of granular decoding means a high-confidence comparison isn't possible. This is typical for Aave proposals of this format and not itself a red flag, so no discrepancies are flagged, but confidence is set to low given the limited visibility into the payload's actual sub-actions. Delegates relying on this analysis should also consult the linked implementation contract source (AaveV3Ethereum_AaveLiquidityCommiteeFunding_20240306.sol) to confirm the internal steps match the specification (withdraw 250k USDT/USDC, swap for GHO, and grant a 500k GHO allowance to 0x205e795336610f5131Be52F09218AF19f0f3eC60), since that level of detail is not present in the decoded action list provided here.", "discrepancies":[]}
Generated by Kvorum
04Actions
- Target
- 0x27dd…4354
- Value
- 0 wei
- Function
- fallback()
- Arguments
{}- Calldata
05Tally
Summed from votes
06Voters
No votes recorded yet.
07Forum
No forum thread is confidently linked to this proposal.
08Similar proposals
- aaveexecutedAave Liquidity Committee Funding Phase VI92%
- aaveexecutedAave Liquidity Committee Funding Phase IV91%
- aaveexecutedAave Liquidity Committee Funding Phase V90%
- aaveexecutedFund GHO Liquidity Committee89%
- aaveexecutedGHO Funding88%
- aaveexecutedCEX Earn Funding Proposal86%
- aaveexecutedAave Liquidity Committee Funding Phase VII86%
- aaveexecutedGHO Gnosis Launch82%
- aaveexecutedOnboard GHO and Migrate Streams to Prime Instance82%
- aaveexecutedGHO Avalanche Launch82%