KVORUM
aaveSource: Aave governance v3 · #216

Increase Borrow Slope1 to all Stablecoins across all Aave Instances

executedDec 14, 2024, 10:44 PM UTCby570x57ab…2922

01Summary

AISummary by Kvorumclaude-haiku-4-5

This proposal increases the borrow slope1 parameter (the first segment of the interest rate curve) for stablecoins to 12.5% across Aave V2 Ethereum and all Aave V3 instances (Ethereum, Avalanche, Polygon, Optimism, Arbitrum, Base, Metis, BNB Chain, Scroll, Gnosis, and ZkSync). Some assets with different current rates (like USDC.e, USDbC, and GHO) are increased to 13.5% or adjusted according to their specific current rates. The proposal also adjusts slope2 parameters for V3 instances. The goal is to optimize interest rates to reflect current market conditions, increase protocol revenue,

Type
parameter change

Key changes

  • Increase borrow slope1 for stablecoins (USDC, USDT, DAI, USDe, FRAX, LUSD, PYUSD, crvUSD, EURS, sUSD, GHO, WXDAI, EURe, and others) from current rates (primarily 5.5%, with some assets at 6.0%-10%) to 12.5% across all Aave V3 instances and Aave V2 on Ethereum(high)
  • Adjust slope1 for certain wrapped stablecoins (USDC.e on Polygon, Optimism, Arbitrum, Gnosis; USDbC on Base) to 13.5% from current rates of 9%-10%(high)
  • Introduce slope2 parameters for Aave V3 instances where they were previously not specified, setting them to values ranging from 35%-50% depending on the asset and market(medium)
  • Modify slope2 values for Aave V3 Core and other instances to specific percentages (e.g., USDC slope2 from 75% to 35% on Ethereum V3 Core)(medium)

Notable concerns

  • This is a broad, multi-chain parameter change affecting stablecoins across 11+ blockchain instances and 2 Aave versions simultaneously
  • The increase of slope1 by 127% (from 5.5% to 12.5%) significantly raises borrowing costs for stablecoins, which could reduce demand for stablecoin borrows if users migrate to other protocols
  • The proposal relies on the assumption that higher utilization in stablecoin markets will persist, which may not hold if market conditions change
  • Some assets have differential treatment (wrapped stablecoins at 13.5%), which could create rate disparities and incentivize certain market segments
Contracts0xc2c67ce19924d5befd42a3fb96f5e01d3acdae170xd8c8fc05d5a5e5a04b527abaea0110624d4ffbc50x772c2a2aa905363d9958bcfd4f6891fc876dca440xe5a064e8380dd6984562d207542f2cf036ae887e
Generated by Kvorum
model: claude-haiku-4-5
provider: anthropic
profile: anthropic-fast-v1
prompt: v1.0
generated: 2mo ago
Read the description ↗

02Description

970 words

Simple Summary

This proposal recommends increasing the borrow slope1 parameter for stablecoins across all Aave V3 Instances and Aave V2 on mainnet to 12.5%. This adjustment aims to align interest rate models with the updated Stable Debt Reserve (SDR) strategy, promoting sustainability, better risk management, and optimal utilization of the protocol’s resources.

Motivation

The current market environment presents a unique opportunity to optimize Aave’s interest rate parameters. With the introduction of sUSDe as E-Mode collateral and general market sentiment leading to higher desire for borrowing, we are seeing significantly higher utilisation in the stablecoin market. This adjustment to the borrow slope1 will better align Aave’s interest rates with prevailing market conditions, potentially leading to:

  • Increased protocol revenue through better rate optimization
  • Enhanced capital efficiency by maintaining competitive lending rates at lower volatility.

Additionally, this change will ensure appropriate risk compensation for stablecoin lenders.

Specification

MarketAssetCurrent Slope1Recommended Slope1Current Slope2Recommended Slope2
Ethereum V2USDC5.5%12.5%60%-
Ethereum V2USDT5.5%12.5%100%-
Ethereum V2DAI5.5%12.5%75%-
Ethereum V3 CoreUSDC5.5%12.5%75%35%
Ethereum V3 CoreUSDT5.5%12.5%75%35%
Ethereum V3 CoreUSDe9.0%12.5%75%50%
Ethereum V3 CoreFRAX5.5%12.5%75%40%
Ethereum V3 CoreDAI5.5%12.5%75%35%
Ethereum V3 CoreLUSD5.5%12.5%87%50%
Ethereum V3 CorePYUSD5.5%12.5%80%50%
Ethereum V3 CorecrvUSD5.5%12.5%80%50%
Ethereum V3 PrimeUSDC5.5%12.5%60%35%
Ethereum V3 EtherFiUSDC6.5%12.5%60%40%
Ethereum V3 EtherFiPYUSD5.5%12.5%80%40%
Ethereum V3 EtherFiFRAX5.5%12.5%80%40%
Avalanche V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
Avalanche V3USDT5.5%12.5%75%40%
Avalanche V3DAI5.5%12.5%75%40%
Avalanche V3FRAX5.5%12.5%75%40%
Polygon V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
Polygon V3USDC.e10.0%13.5%80%40%
Polygon V3USDT5.5%12.5%75%40%
Polygon V3DAI5.5%12.5%75%40%
Polygon V3EURS5.5%12.5%75%50%
Optimism V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
Optimism V3USDT5.5%12.5%75%40%
Optimism V3DAI5.5%12.5%75%40%
Optimism V3sUSD5.5%12.5%75%50%
Optimism V3LUSD5.5%12.5%87%50%
Optimism V3USDC.e6.5%13.5%80%40%
Arbitrum V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
Arbitrum V3USDC.e6.5%13.5%80%40%
Arbitrum V3USDT5.5%12.5%75%40%
Arbitrum V3DAI5.5%12.5%75%40%
Arbitrum V3LUSD5.5%12.5%87%50%
Arbitrum V3FRAX5.5%12.5%75%40%
Arbitrum V3GHO12%12.5%65%40%
Base V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
Base V3USDbC10.0%13.5%80%40%
Metis V3m.USDC6.0%12.5%60%40%
Metis V3m.USDT6.0%12.5%75%40%
Metis V3m.DAI7.0%12.5%75%50%
BNB Chain V3USDT5.5%12.5%75%40%
BNB Chain V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
BNB Chain V3FDUSD5.5%12.5%75%40%
Scroll V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
Gnosis V3WXDAI5.5%12.5%75%40%
Gnosis V3USDC5.5%12.5%75%40%
Gnosis V3EURe5.5%12.5%75%50%
Gnosis V3USDC.e9%13.5%75%40%
ZKSync V3USDC5.5%12.5%60%40%
ZKSync V3USDT5.5%12.5%60%40%

References

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.

03Mismatch analysis

AIMismatch analysis by Kvorumlow confidenceclaude-sonnet-5
Consistent

The proposal description contains a very detailed table specifying exact slope1/slope2 interest-rate parameter changes for dozens of stablecoin reserves across 15+ Aave V2/V3 deployments on multiple chains. However, the decoded on-chain calldata only shows four generic execute() (fallback) calls to four distinct mainnet contract addresses, with no decoded function arguments. This is the typical pattern for Aave cross-chain governance, where the top-level AIP payload dispatches to per-network 'payload' contracts (matching the linked GitHub implementation files) that internally encode the specific rate parameter updates via delegatecall; the actual per-asset slope changes are not visible in this top-level decoded calldata. Because the calldata gives no visibility into the specific numeric parameters being set, it is not possible to directly verify or refute the specific percentages and market targets claimed in the description (e.g., 12.5% vs 13.5% slope1, or the various slope2 reductions). There is no evidence of a mismatch — the number of distinct target contracts (4, likely corresponding to grouped ecosystem reserves factories/payloads bundling multiple chain-specific executions or a subset of the referenced repos) is plausible given the proposal's multi-chain scope — but without deeper introspection into the called payload contracts' internal logic, a full one-to-one verification of every table row against calldata cannot be performed. Given this opacity, confidence is set to low and no specific value/target discrepancies are flagged, since doing so would require speculation beyond the provided decoded data. Nothing in the visible calldata contradicts the description, and no unexpected actions (transfers, role grants, etc.) are apparent beyond the expected governance execution pattern.

Generated by Kvorum
model: claude-sonnet-5
provider: anthropic
profile: anthropic-strong-v1
prompt: v1.0
generated: 2mo ago
Review the decoded actions ↗

04Actions

4 total
#0fallback()chain 0x1
Target
0xc2c6…ae17
Value
0 wei
Function
fallback()
Arguments
{}
Calldata
#1fallback()chain 0x1
Target
0xd8c8…fbc5
Value
0 wei
Function
fallback()
Arguments
{}
Calldata
#2fallback()chain 0x1
Target
0x772c…ca44
Value
0 wei
Function
fallback()
Arguments
{}
Calldata
#3fallback()chain 0x1
Target
0xe5a0…887e
Value
0 wei
Function
fallback()
Arguments
{}
Calldata

05Tally

Summed from votes

Voters0
VP participating0
Outcome (current)—
Current support—

06Voters

0 total

No votes recorded yet.

07Forum

No forum thread is confidently linked to this proposal.